GENERAL PROCEDURE
Have students locate the EDITORIAL PAGES, using the e-Replica Table of Contents. You may wish to lead a discussion on the differences between fact and opinion as an introduction to this exercise.
For further study of the editorial cartoon, go to https://nie.washingtonpost.com/content/inside-journalism-editorial-cartoons
1. Explain the concept of an editorial cartoon. The editorial or political cartoonist is commenting on current events. Use examples from the Tom Toles’ Editorial Cartoon and the Saturday OP-ED pages of MAIN NEWS. Emphasize the use of symbolism, caricatures, exaggeration and details.
Have students suggest issues and concerns in their lives. Challenge each student to create a cartoon expressing his or her opinion about one of these issues.
2. Select an editorial cartoon and answer the following questions:
- If the cartoon has a title, what current event does it refer to or suggest? To what historical event does it refer or suggest?
- What is the subject of the cartoon?
- Does the cartoonist make us of caricatures? If yes, how effective are they?
- What is the viewpoint of the cartoonist?
- Do you agree or disagree with the cartoonist’s point of view?
3. Clip editorial cartoons that appear in The Washington Post. Former Washington Post publisher Philip Graham called journalism the “first draft of history.” How might an editorial/ political cartoon be considered the first draft of history? Discuss and analyze the work of Tom Toles and other cartoonists for their visual perspective and political point of view.
Academic Content Standards and Skills
Maryland
Reading/English Language Arts, Students will determine and analyze important ideas and messages in informational texts [cartoons]. Identify and explain the argument, viewpoint and perspective.
Virginia
Social Science, The student will develop skills for historical analysis, including the ability to analyze documents, records and data (such as artifacts, diaries, letters, photographs, journals, newspapers).
Washington, D.C.
Reading/English, Language Arts, Grade 5, Language as Meaning Making, Students comprehend and compose a wide range of written, oral and visual texts; Applies thinking strategies to aid understanding (including ability to question, summarize, analyze, compare, interpret and evaluate).
Fundamental Aim
Reinforce Interpreting
Sub-skill Reinforcement
Categorizing, distinguishing fact from opinion, critical thinking, drawing conclusions, analyzing, developing visual imagery
Read and Write a Letter to the Editor
GENERAL PROCEDURE
Have students locate the OP-ED PAGE, using the Table of Contents on e-Replica. You may wish to lead a discussion on the differences between fact and opinion as an introduction to this exercise. The newspaper has a duty to inform its community. Why is it important to provide readers a voice through LETTERS TO THE EDITOR?
Ask students if they write letters to anyone? A thank you note after receiving a gift or a letter to a relative to express affection might be familiar to them. Do they use e-mail to send notes? Why do they send notes or write letters? Distinguish informal notes from formal letters.
Note: LETTERS TO THE EDITOR exercises can be modified for use with other sections of The Washington Post that offer a Letters to the Editor column.
2. Encourage students to exchange opinions about an issue dealt with in one or more editorials or LETTERS TO THE EDITOR. Assist students in conducting a classroom survey to determine the positions taken relative to the issue. Consider adding demographic elements to the collection of survey information (boys vs. girls, those who live less than a mile from school vs. those who live more than a mile from school, those who use public facilities vs. those who go to private clubs or home facilities for sports activities). Using bar graphs or picture graphs, students can work in pairs or small groups to create visuals depicting the results of the poll.
3. Have students read the LETTERS TO THE EDITOR for a week. Students will choose one letter of interest to them and research the original editorial, column or article to which the letter responds. Have students consider the strengths and weaknesses of the letter writer’s arguments and, based upon the analysis, have students write a new Letter to the Editor or create an editorial cartoon supporting or rebutting the position of the original letter.
Academic Content Standards and Skills
Maryland
Reading/English Language Arts, Students will compose to express personal ideas to develop fluency using a variety of forms, such as journals, narratives, letters, reports and paragraphs.
Virginia
English, Grade 11, The student will write, revise, and edit personal, professional and informational correspondence to a standard acceptable in the work place and higher education. Organize information to support the purpose of the writing.
Washington, D.C.
Reading/English Language Arts, Grade 5, Language as Meaning Making, Students comprehend and compose a wide range of written, oral and visual texts; Applies thinking strategies to aid understanding (including ability to question, summarize, analyze, compare, interpret and evaluate).
Fundamental Aim
Reinforce Interpreting
Sub-skill Reinforcement
Categorizing, distinguishing fact from opinion, critical thinking, drawing conclusions, evaluating
Culture and Geography Through the Eyes of a Foreign Correspondent
GENERAL PROCEDURE
The FOREIGN JOURNAL appears occasionally in MAIN NEWS. It chronicles a foreign correspondent’s observations on the lifestyle, the culture and the people to which the correspondent is currently assigned in that country or region.
The Washington Post has a commitment to providing international news as well as local news. It has 20 foreign bureaus. In addition, reporters are sent to cover news in many parts of the world.
1. After reading and saving the FOREIGN JOURNAL for six weeks, have students list four or six countries referenced within the FOREIGN JOURNAL. Locate these countries on a map. Lead students in a discussion of what they already know about these countries (weather, style of dress, food, animal life, religion, its music and arts).
What new information does the foreign correspondent provide?
What else do they wish to know about each country, its people and its culture? Brainstorm with the class as to where they might find answers to their questions.
Divide the class into groups; each group has a different country to study. Have students research this country by having the groups write to bureaus of tourism, its embassy and other sources they have listed. Each group is to design a series of posters focusing on this country and present an oral report to the class. Posters should reflect past and present aspects of the country. Compile a list of resources that were used to prepare the poster and presentation.
2. Have students choose a FOREIGN JOURNAL portrait of a country which interests them. Students are to imagine that a foreign exchange student from that country will be arriving next fall to attend your school. What will this foreign exchange student need to know about our country and your community? Using the information learned from FOREIGN JOURNAL and related newspaper articles, students are to prepare a letter to the exchange student which compares and contrasts the two cultures.
3. Read the FOREIGN JOURNAL for several months. Select a country. What perspective on that country’s competitions, conflicts and cooperation with other countries is gained through reading FOREIGN JOURNAL?
Read other pages in The Post to learn more about the selected country.
•Look for news articles for examples of competitions, conflicts or cooperation in the country.
•How do current events impact on the daily life and culture of the country?
•In what region is the focus country located?
•Do the articles indicate conflict and the causes of that conflict?
•What efforts are being made in the country by such organizations as the United Nations, the International Red Cross and other humanitarian organizations?
•What world nations are involved in promoting cooperation with the focus country?
•Are initiatives taking place in this country by the International Monetary Fund, World Bank, or health care initiatives?
Academic Content Standards and Skills
Maryland
Social Studies, History, Students will analyze the major sources of tension, cooperation, and conflict in the world and the efforts that have been made to address them.
Virginia
World Geography, The student will analyze how the forces of conflict and cooperation affect the division and control of the Earth’s surface by explaining and analyzing the different spatial divisions, analyzing ways cooperation occurs to solve problems and settle disputes.
Washington, D.C.
Social Studies, Geography, Human Systems, Students understand how economic, political and social processes interact to shape patterns of human population, interdependence, cooperation, competition, compromise and conflicts in controlling the Earth’s surface.
Fundamental Aim
Reinforce Interacting
Sub-skill Reinforcement
Locating information, comparing and contrasting, categorizing, decision making, drawing conclusions
Target Markets in Advertisements
GENERAL PROCEDURE
Introductory discussion should note that a primary goal of most advertising is to create business and profit for the company whose products or services are being featured. Are there exceptions to this principle?
Students need to know the definition of “target-group marketing.” Explain that successful marketing depends upon knowing who the buyer is and what the buyer wants or needs. The “target” is the segment of the population to which an advertiser aims its message and product or service.
Using the MAIN NEWS section, students will scan the newspaper for advertising. This exercise can be done individually or in groups.
Use the worksheet, "Exploration of Advertising" for a Level 3 activity.
For further study of advertising, downloading the following curriculum guides:
"INSIDE Journalism: Keep the 'Ad'itude"
"Pencil Points"
1. Explain that successful marketing depends upon knowing who the buyer is and what the buyer wants or needs. Have students choose an advertisement from MAIN NEWS which is NOT accompanied by a picture. Ask them to assume the role of the marketing manager who submitted the item. Their supervisor has asked for a picture to go with the advertisement.
Based on their understanding of the advertisement’s product/service and target market, students are to write a description of the picture they need from the photographer or commercial artist to illustrate their story. The response can also include their own rendition of the illustration needed.
2. Have students work in pairs to print out advertisements from the MAIN NEWS section. Then, students are to separate the ads into the following categories. (Based on a prior perusal of the MAIN NEWS ads, alternate or additional categories can be used.)
•Ads intended for women
•Ads intended for men
•Ads intended for businesses
•Ads intended for household decision-makers
•Ads intended for general audiences
Or
Have students separate the ads by type of advertisement. What categories of advertisement are found most in the MAIN NEWS section? These categories might include home furnishings, travel and clothing. They could then print out advertising found in the METRO, LOCAL LIVING or another section.
In grouping the ads, students should also take note if there is a predominance of certain types of products or services featured within the ads targeting any one group (for example, clothes for women, toys for children, home improvement products/services for heads of households). Does the section of the newspaper influence where types of ads are placed?
A graph can be created to compare the number of ads targeting each type of buyer.
Lead the class in a discussion about what they have learned about advertising. What conclusions can students draw about advertising?
3. Worksheet: "Exploration of Advertising"
Academic Content Standards and Skills
Maryland
Social Studies, Grade 4, Economics, Students will explain how scarcity and availability of the economic resources [natural, human, capital] determine what is produced and the effects on consumers in Maryland.
Virginia
Social Science, Civics and Economics, The student will demonstrate knowledge of how economic decisions are made in the marketplace by applying the concepts of price, incentives, supply and demand.
Washington, D.C.
Reading/English Language Arts, Grade 6, Language for Social Communication, The student determines and categorizes the advertising techniques that target specific audiences.
Fundamental Aim
Reinforce Performing a Task
Sub-skill Reinforcement
Locating information, finding the main idea, critical thinking, predicting outcomes, analyzing, drawing conclusions, evaluating, developing visual imagery
Read About The Environment
GENERAL PROCEDURE
THE ENVIRONMENT appears on Mondays in MAIN NEWS. Using several “editions” of THE ENVIRONMENT, lead students in a consideration and inventorying of the devices used within this Monday feature to clarify the presentation of highly technical information and, at the same time, economize on space and text. Review the devices so students can differentiate and identify each.
Use the worksheet "Ways to Illustrate Technical Information" for a Level 3 activity. You may want your students to create a notebook of these examples from THE ENVIRONMENT or place the collection in a special section of a notebook they keep.
1. Over a period of one to four Mondays, read THE ENVIRONMENT with your students. During this period, students are to keep a learning log listing the topics covered. Students should also list in the log those words from the article which are unfamiliar to them. As often as possible, assist students in using context to define these words in their own terms. Simple definitions of purely technical terminology should be given to students if (1) the context is of no help and (2) the word is important to understanding the article.
If an article (or a portion of an article) is of particular interest, students should print the article and any related illustrations and place it with the corresponding page in their learning logs. At the end of the month-long review of THE ENVIRONMENT, students can report on their favorite article, summarizing what was learned from the feature. If applicable, the report should include references to the chapter or portion of the class’s science text in which the topic is discussed or is related.
2. Lead students in discussing THE ENVIRONMENT for four Mondays. Special attention should be given to the illustrative pictures, graphs and photographs.
A folder or a portion of the student’s notebook should be designated for filing the four THE ENVIRONMENT articles.
After the fourth Monday, each student will select one feature or portion of a feature from the file which is of special interest. A brief report that includes the following elements will be given to the class.
1. A summary of the feature’s information;
2. An explanation of why this topic is of special interest to the student;
3. One student-produced model, illustration or photograph which illustrates the topic in some way (for example, a representation of a process or principle, an example of the element); and
4. Three additional resources for further information on the subject. Sources may include books, people, specific organizations or departments within organizations and Internet sites.
Extension: Select a chapter of study within your science text to review the illustrations. Compare and contrast how the information was presented in the textbook to how information is presented in THE ENVIRONMENT. Evaluate how effectively concepts are illustrated. Offer suggestions to the publisher of your textbook.
3. Worksheet: "Ways to Illustrate Technical Information"
Academic Content Standards and Skills
Maryland
Science, Skills and Processes, Students will collect, organize, and accurately display data collected from investigations.
Virginia
English, Proficient use of the English language will enable students to explore and articulate the complex issues and ideas encountered in public and personal life.
Washington, D.C.
Science, Scientific Inquiry, Students communicate and defend ideas, explanations and models in a variety of formats. Read science-related materials to understand science from a historical perspective and to be informed of current scientific advances and issues.
Fundamental Aim
Reinforce Performing a Task
Sub-skill Reinforcement
Following directions, locating information, finding the main idea, identifying, drawing conclusions, analyzing, evaluating, developing visual imagery
Follow the Supreme Court
GENERAL PROCEDURE
Review the executive, legislative and judicial branches of government. Lead students in a discussion about what they know or do not know about the Supreme Court. What is the role of the Supreme Court? When does the Supreme Court convene?
Have students locate articles about the Supreme Court using e-Replica’s search feature.
Know your students and use your professional judgment. Supreme Court articles can be reserved for classroom inclusion when case topics are developmentally appropriate to your students’ level of understanding and relation to your subject area.
Note: The SUPREME COURT CALENDAR appears only when the Court is in session. These exercises can be modified for use with articles about the United States Congress. Have students follow the issues and events that are the focus of committee hearings and congressional debate.
1. Have students follow the Supreme Court for several days and determine what cases are being heard. Students should choose one case and determine how this case will affect them, their family and/or their community.
2. From the articles in MAIN NEWS about the Supreme Court, have students select a case to be heard or reviewed by the Court. Use the article chosen and any related news stories to draw students’ attention to the fact that the topic is up for Supreme Court action.
Allow students to share their views on the subject. Ask them to register an opinion on the issue. Encourage and facilitate students’ following media coverage and any Court activity on the case over the next several weeks. Are their standings/opinions influenced? Changed? Unchanged?
Explain to students that several months will pass from the Court’s hearing of the case to the day the Court’s decision is announced. For example, Tinker v. Des Moines Independent Community School District was argued on Nov. 12, 1968, and decided on Feb. 24, 1969. At the Oyez Project (http://oyez.org/) you can find “The Pending Docket” which provides title, docket number, date argued, facts, question presented and conclusion. This site also provides legal resources, Supreme Court case summaries, Oyez Baseball and links to a Supreme Court Virtual Tour and FindLaw.
When the ruling is announced, how many students were with the majority opinion? How many were with the minority opinion?
3. Have students follow the Supreme Court over a period of several weeks. From the cases heard by the Court during this period, have students choose one of interest and locate news stories/editorials related to the subject of the case. Using these as their sources, students will prepare a legal “brief” abstracting the facts related to the topic (for example, statistics, potential demographic or geographic impact of a favorable or unfavorable decision). A concluding portion of the abstract will be a decision forecast, a supported prediction of how the Court is expected to rule.
“We the Students: Supreme Court Cases for and about Students,” by Jamin Raskin, is an excellent resource for this activity. Raskin, a professor of constitutional law and the First Amendment at American University’s Washington College of Law and founder of its Marshall-Brennan Fellows Program, includes a chapter on how to brief a case.
Academic Content Standards and Skills
Maryland
Social Studies, Political Systems, Students will demonstrate understanding of the evolution and changing interpretations of the United States Constitution and its Amendments.
Virginia
Government, The student will demonstrate knowledge of the operation of the federal judiciary by describing how the Supreme Court decides cases.
Washington, D.C.
History, American Government, Grade 12, Principles and Practices, The student analyzes political and legal issues in contemporary American society and how Supreme Court decisions have affected these issues.
Fundamental Aim
Developing Positive Attitudes and Personal Interests
Sub-skill Reinforcement
Locating information, decision making, drawing conclusions, analyzing, evaluating, predicting outcomes, critical thinking
Opinion Options
GENERAL PROCEDURE
Everyone has an opinion about something. In the world of persuasion and commentary, opinion is not enough. Facts and details are needed. Have students locate the OP-ED PAGE by using the e-Replica Table of Contents.
This exercise can reinforce or introduce a lesson that focuses on distinguishing between fact and opinion and/or features the nature and purpose of the editorial section of MAIN NEWS.
The Level 1 exercise should be used as a preparation for the Level 2 exercise.
Go to “INSIDE Journalism: Composing Columns.” for further study of column and commentary writing.
1. In preparation for this exercise, choose an OP-ED columnist’s feature and a related news item from MAIN NEWS. Introduce the topic, issue or event covered by the article and column and lead students in a reading of both items. (Note: The objective of the reading is to demonstrate the differences between the two articles, an OP-ED column and a MAIN NEWS article; it may not be necessary to read both pieces completely to accomplish this objective.)
Lead students in a discussion of how the items differ. Primarily, contrast the actual/objective nature of the news article with the opinionated/subjective nature of the columnist’s article. Students may be asked to re-read all or a portion of the articles and underline or otherwise highlight the statements of fact in each. Which has the greatest proportion of factual statements? Which has the greatest proportion of opinion?
2. Divide students into two groups. One is a group of “reporters”; the other is a group of “columnists.” Direct each group’s attention to an event familiar to all students. An excerpt could be taken from a literature selection (Make Way for Ducklings, The Diary of Anne Frank, The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn), from a subject area textbook (social studies or government), or from a standard folk/fairy tale (Goldilocks’ entry into the house of The Three Bears, Cinderella leaving the ball). The “reporters” are to draft a report of the event as it would appear on Page 1 of a newspaper. The “columnists” are to draft a column responding to the event as it would appear on the newspaper’s editorial page.
3. Have students choose a topic of interest featured within one of the columns of the OP-ED contributors. Over a two-week period, students will follow the selected topic as it is treated within related news and feature stories, editorials, letters to the editor and editorial cartoons. During the study, special attention is given to the point of view represented within/by each treatment of the topic. If possible, the articles and other readings should be clipped or printed out and saved for reference.
At the end of the second week, an analysis is done to determine the number of perspectives represented within the two weeks of coverage. How many viewpoints are presented? What are they? (Man-on-the-street? Politician? Consumer? Senior citizen? Young professional?) In the opinion of the analyst(s), what, if any, important viewpoint has been omitted?
The students are to prepare/present an oral or written summary on the two weeks of media coverage. The summary should NOT focus on agreeing or disagreeing with the issue but, rather, focus only on the degree to which multiple perspectives were represented.
Extension: If the analysis concludes that an important perspective was not presented, students can write an essay or column addressing the topic or issue from this missing perspective.
Academic Content Standards and Skills
Maryland
Reading/English Language Arts, Students will compose to express personal ideas by experimenting with a variety of forms and techniques suited to topic, audience and purpose.
Virginia
English, Grade 8, The student will write in a variety of forms, including narrative, expository, persuasive and informational.
Washington, D.C.
Reading/English Language Arts, Grade 5, Language for Research and Inquiry, The student summarizes and critiques two or more local newspaper articles dealing with the same topic or issue.
Fundamental Aim
Reinforce Interacting
Sub-skill Reinforcement
Locating information, finding the main idea, comparing and contrasting, distinguishing fact from opinion, critical thinking, drawing conclusions, analyzing, evaluating
Check Out the Nation
GENERAL PROCEDURE
Point out to students that Politics & The Nation Digest feature abstracts of
news stories occurring in various parts of the country. Note that local and/or regional papers serving the geographic area within which each story occurs very likely carry much more lengthy accounts of the event. Have students consider the importance of a writer being able to distill a long, detailed account of an event into a brief summary. This exercise can be conducted over one or more consecutive days and completed individually or in groups.
The Level 2 exercise could be used to introduce or follow up a lesson on the 5W’s and one H — who, what, when, where, why, and how.
The exercises can also be modified for The World Digest.
1. A dateline is the city (and state or country, if confusion is likely) at the start of the story that tells where the reporter is if he or she is not in the local area. The date may be included if the article was written before that day’s newspaper.
Using Politics & The Nation Digest, have students note the dateline for each story and discuss what they already know about this city or state. Students will then locate each story’s origin on a United States map.
Extension: This exercise can be extended to a social studies project where students, at the end of a two-week period, list those states not covered in Politics & The Nation Digest and prepare a report on those states for the class.
2. Select four or five news articles from Politics & The Nation. Ask students to choose one of the articles to abstract as if it were to appear in Politics & The Nation Digest. A length limit might be established for the finished abstract. For example, the abstract might be limited to one half, one third, or one fourth the number of sentences used in the original article. (An abstract of an article of 24 sentences could be no more than 12, 8 or 6 sentences in length.)
3. Consider with students how the Politics & The Nation Digest section
of the paper may be thought of as a snapshot of our country or as a barometer of the national condition. Have students follow the news briefs carried in Politics & The Nation Digest for two weeks. The title of each abstract should be recorded and rated
in regard to its report of news using the following code:
+ = Good News
0 = Neither Good Nor Bad News
– = Bad News
Students should create a three-column chart on which to record their data. In the first column, they should record the title of the article. In the second column, record the symbol. In the third column, record for whom this is good, bad or indifferent news. This third column will indicate why they gave the rating of “+,” “0” or “-.”
At the end of the two weeks, students should prepare a report on their findings. The paper should present an objective report summarizing the data analysis (the number and/or percent of “+,” “0,” and “–” stories). The use of graphic presentations in the report (bar graphs, pie charts) should be encouraged. The report should conclude with a personal
response from the researcher/author expressing a subjective reaction to the findings. Examples of personal responses to positive or negative observations can be found within the EDITORIAL or OP-ED section of the paper.
Academic Content Standards and Skills
Maryland
Reading/English Language Arts, Students will demonstrate their ability to write to express personal ideas by selecting a form and its appropriate elements.
Virginia
English, Grade 10, The student will critique professional and peer writing.
Washington, D.C.
Reading/English Language Arts, Grade 5, Language for Research and Inquiry, The student summarizes and critiques two or more local newspaper articles dealing with the same topic or issue.
Fundamental Aim
Reinforce Performing a Task
Sub-skill Reinforcement
Locating information, finding the main idea, identifying, drawing conclusions, evaluating