GENERAL PROCEDURE
Have students locate the different METRO columnists (see introduction to this section for a list of METRO section columnists).
Like editorial writers, columnists express their opinions about people, actions and events.
This exercise may be done over a period of time and individually or in groups.
Go to https://nie.washingtonpost.com/content/inside-journalism-composing-columns for further study of column and commentary writing. This guide contains an interview with former Washington Post columnist Marc Fisher and an article that Fisher wrote for KidsPost readers.
1. To develop as strategic readers, students need to recognize the difference between fact and opinion. Direct students’ attention to a columnist from the METRO section whose topic would have appeal to the class. For younger students, you may wish to use the Marc Fisher column included in the Post online guide, “INSIDE Journalism: Composing Columns.”
Before reading the column aloud, lead students in a brief pre-reading discussion about the topic. Discussion should focus on what students already know about the subject/topic.
List all contributions on the chalkboard or overhead. Once the list is developed, ask students to help you label each contribution as a fact (F) or an opinion (O).
In telling what they know about the topic, did students offer more opinions or more facts? Explain to students that as readers, writers, listeners and speakers, it is important to recognize the difference between fact and opinion. Ask the class to follow along as you read the column (or a portion of the column) aloud. After the reading, students should label each statement as a fact (F) or an opinion (O).
Questions like the following can help students analyze their labeling.
•Were facts or opinions found more often within the column?
•Can someone disagree with facts?
•Can someone disagree with opinions?
•Are facts or opinions more persuasive?
•Why is it important to know the difference between facts and opinions?
Based on their writing, how do reporters differ from columnists?
If students keep a writing folder or journal, they may find it interesting to survey a few pieces of their own writing. How do the number (or proportion) of facts and opinions compare?
Extension: Use the above procedure with a news article about the same topic covered by the columnist. Compare the results.
Extension: This activity could be expanded into a discussion that considers the importance of this type of strategic reading and listening as related to being politically aware and/or being a wise consumer.
Extension: Ask students to consider how the balance of fact and opinion shifts depending on the type of writing or reading being done: research, personal, creative, persuasive, expository, narrative.
2. Have students read the FEDERAL DIARY by Joe Davidson and outline the subjects discussed in the articles. Students should make special notes of facts, figures, and data mentioned in the column.
Choosing one of the topics from their readings, students should explain why this information would be of importance to a federal employee. Students should also make note of the additional resources mentioned by Joe Davidson in the FEDERAL DIARY to complete this assignment.
3. For two weeks, lead students in a reading and discussion of METRO columnists. You may wish to select from Petula Dvorak, Robert McCartney and Courtland Milloy. More than the columnist’s opinion or stand on an issue, the during-reading and post-reading discussions should focus on the columnists’ writing styles.
During these readings and discussions, students should keep journals or records of particularly effective writing examples (e.g., a powerful word choice, an especially effective simile or metaphor, a striking analogy or allusion, notable opening and/or ending statements). Have students refer to these journal or log entries as they consider and discuss the writing style of each columnist.
Questions such as the following can generate and focus these discussions:
•How does each begin his or her column?
•How is each column ended?
•How is word choice used effectively?
•Are sentences mostly simple and direct or are the structures more complex?
•What is(are) the source(s) of most of the columnist’s analogies or allusions?
•Does the columnist include personal experience?
•Does the columnist quote sources from the community?
•Like TV shows, columnists are said to have a “following.” What about these columnists gives them a following? Their writing? Their opinion? Both?
Academic Content Standards and Skills
Maryland
Reading/English, Language Arts, Students will assess the effectiveness of details, organizational pattern, word choice syntax, use of figurative language and rhetorical devices ….
Virginia
English, Grade 7, The student will distinguish fact from opinion in newspapers, magazines, and other print media. The student will describe how word choice and language structure convey an author’s viewpoint.
Washington, D.C.
Reading/English, Language Arts, Grade 5, Language as Meaning Making, The student recognizes and understands literary devices including metaphors, analogy, irony, exaggeration and personification.
Fundamental Aim:
Reinforce Interpreting
Sub-skill Reinforcement:
Locating information, finding the main idea, comparing and contrasting, distinguishing fact from opinion, critical thinking, drawing conclusions, analyzing